A group of murderous criminals decide to make the ultimate snuff film, only to realize that it might not have the ending they expected in bloody, low-budget shocker. When a bookie's customer pays a debt with a video camera, the bookie and his friend decide to shoot a horror movie. Realizing they're completely lacking the resources and talent to produce anything with real production value, the aspiring auteurs decide to take a more realistic approach to terrorizing the audience. In order to get the right actresses for the job, the filmmakers post a notice for a Devil's Night audition on the internet. If a girl refuses to take off her top during the audition, she is set free; if she agrees, she's dragged down in the basement with the rest of the "cast." The following day, on Halloween, the camera rolls and the games begin. Any girl who wins fair and square is granted her freedom, but the ones who don't meet a bloody end. Just as their masterpiece is nearing completion, however, the girls get the upper hand in a plot twist that no one could see coming.